People ask us this question all the time: "Should I just buy a boat?" It's a fair question and deserves an honest answer. Here's the math as we see it.
The Real Cost of Boat Ownership in Utah
Let's use a mid-range boat as the baseline — something like a 20-22 foot pontoon or bowrider in decent condition. New, that's $40,000–$80,000. Used and nice, you're looking at $20,000–$40,000. Here's what that purchase actually costs you annually:
- Depreciation — Boats depreciate fast, especially in the first few years. Figure 8–12% per year on a newer boat. On a $50,000 boat that's $4,000–$6,000 per year just in lost value.
- Storage — Dry stack or covered storage in Utah runs $100–$250/month. Over a year: $1,200–$3,000.
- Insurance — Recreational boat insurance in Utah typically runs $500–$1,500/year depending on the boat and your record.
- Registration and taxes — Utah charges sales tax on boat purchases and annual registration fees. Budget $200–$600/year ongoing.
- Maintenance — Oil changes, winterization, propeller repairs, upholstery, bilge pump, electronics. Budget conservatively $800–$2,000/year for a well-maintained boat.
- Fuel — A full day on the water burns 20–40 gallons depending on the engine. At current prices that's $60–$150 per trip in fuel alone.
Add it up: a $50,000 boat costs you roughly $8,000–$12,000 per year just to own, before fuel, before any major repairs.
When Ownership Makes Sense
If you're genuinely going out 25+ times per year, ownership can make financial sense and the convenience factor is real. You wake up and go. No scheduling, no pickup, no returning. If boating is your primary outdoor hobby and you use it constantly, the math starts to work out.
Also: if you have a place to store a boat for free (property with a garage or yard), the economics improve significantly.
When Renting Makes More Sense
For most Utah families, renting is the smarter move. The average boat owner uses their boat 8–12 times per year. At that frequency, renting is dramatically cheaper than ownership — especially when you factor in depreciation and storage.
Renting also means you always have a well-maintained, current-year boat. No surprise repair bills. No winterizing. No insurance paperwork. You pay for what you use and you're done.
The Honest Number
At our rate of $600/day for the Sea-Doo Switch Sport, you'd spend $6,000 to rent it 10 times in a year. Ownership of a comparable boat costs you $8,000–$12,000 annually just in carrying costs — before fuel. The break-even point, accounting for all ownership costs, is somewhere around 20–25 uses per year for most people.
Our Take
If you boat 20+ times per year and have somewhere to store a boat affordably, buying probably makes sense. If you boat less than 15 times per year, renting is almost certainly the better financial decision — and it's less hassle. We're biased, obviously, but the math is the math.
Ready to get out there?
Rent Wedowee, our 2024 Sea-Doo Switch Sport, for your next lake day. Or check out the full fleet.
See the Fleet →